Scot McKnight has blogged about the NeoReformed again. Justin Taylor of Between Two Worlds (part of Piper's Desiring God ministries, I think) has responded.
I guess this "controversy" started with Piper and Wright's back and forth about the nature of justification. Although I haven't read either book, to my knowledge the exchange has been pleasant. The two men disagree but do so with a gracious spirit.
However, I guess McKnight wrote a blurb endorsing Wright's new book to which Piper's camp has taken exception.
I like McKnight, Carson, Piper, and Wright. I hope they work it out.
Perhaps I would disagree with the wording McKnight chose on the blurb, but I think that he has a point that there is a growing constituency of Reformed types who see Reformed theology as the only form of evangelicalism. I don't know if Piper falls into that category, but the group exists and seems to be growing in influence.
I only mention it because it touches on what may be a key issue in the American evangelicalism of the future. Is there room in evangelicalism for the non-Reformed? You will notice in McKnight's article that the main "enemy" of the NeoReformed is the New Perspective on Paul, something I have recently endorsed. I think that my theology is closer to Piper and Carson than it is to McKnight, but I am not Reformed.
Prayer For Your Week - O Lord, make us have perpetual love and reverence for your holy Name, for you never fail to help and govern those whom you have set upon the sure foundatio...
10 hours ago